Five Years Jail Sentence for Killing a Deer!

Bolywood’s bad boy Salman Khan finally got a conviction for killing an endangered black buck in Rajasthan in 1998. Co-accused of Salman Khan, were let off for lack of evidence. Judge wanted to make an example out of Salman Khan because of his fan following, because of his stardom. Idea was, so I thought, if a famous person like Salman Khan can be convicted and sent to jail for killing an endangered wildlife, then common people would be more fearful of the law.

Salman Khan has been embroiled in one controversy or other. Other than killing black buck, Salman Khan had allegedly ran over people sleeping on pavement in Mumbai, under influence of alcohol. Salman Khan had also barged into apartment of his ex-girlfriend, Aishwariya Rai, some say he also physically assaulted her. There is no doubt in my mind that Salman Khan must pay for the consequences of his action. Conviction in black buck killing may be the first step. No matter how much money is riding on his shoulders. No matter how many humanitarian work he does. No matter how good a human being Salman Khan is.

Salman Khan was fined Rs. 10, 000 and a jail term of five years, for killing a black buck. I find both penalty of 10, 000 rupees to be ridiculously low and punishment of 5 years in jail to be unusually harshFi. A fine of 10,000 rupees is nothing for a person like Salman Khan. He probably spends more money per day on his pets. By contrast, a jail term of five years for killing a black buck is also way too much. Consider the following two cases:

Sonali Mukherjee was a young beautiful 18 year old girl in 2003. She was living in


Dhanbad, Jharkhand. Three men, Tapas Mitra, Sanjay Paswan, and Brhmadev Hazra, poured acid on her face one night, while she was asleep on the roof of her house. These men thought Sonali to be arrogant and must be taught a lesson. The incidence had turned Sonali’s life upside down permanently. All her family savings was spent fighting court case. Desperate and destitute, she asked presidential permission to commit suicide. In 2014, more than a decade after her ordeal had started, Sonali was given a grade III clerical position in Bokaro Deputy Commissioners office, by Jharkhand government. Today, Sonali is married and has a child.

Men who disfigured Sonali, a young girl with a bright future ahead of her, were sentenced to nine year in jail. They secured bail by appealing high court, came out. These men, did not even spent their term in jail, lead a normal life outside, while Sonali and her family suffered. Contrast this with Salman Khan’s five year for killing a blackbuck.

My second example is about Aruna Shanbaug. Aruna was not as lucky as Sonali.


A nurse in King Edward Memorial Hospital, Mumbai, Aruna was engaged to be married. Of course fate had a different idea. One day, Aruna Shanbhag had the misfortune of scolding a ward boy. Angry ward boy, Sohanlal Walmiki, attacked Aruna while she was changing to go home for the day. Aruna was raped, strangled with a chain and left to die. Her body was discovered next morning, almost 12 hours later. Aruna did not die, she went into coma instead, and remained in coma for 42 years, from 1973 till 2015.

Sohanlal, was sentenced to two consecutive seven year sentences. He served his terms, changed his city, got married and lived a normal life. All the while, Shanbhag remained in coma.  Reports suggest Sohanlal has been repenting his act and his remaining life is a penance. But consider this, Sohanlal made a vegetable out a vibrant human being and spent 14 years in jail,  while Salman Khan killed a blackbuck and got 5 years.



6 thoughts on “Five Years Jail Sentence for Killing a Deer!

Add yours

  1. These cases point out the oddities in the Indian judicial system, Yes, 5 years seems to be too long a term for killing a blackbuck, Also though 10,000 is almost nothing for a person like him, yet if some petty hunter /smuggler had killed the blackbuck (of which the chances might be higher), they may not had the capacity to pay a higher fine. Since the law has to be the same for all that’s why maybe.
    What is more surprising is how he got away with crushing people on the footpath. Or how these people got away with a smaller sentence after spoiling the lives of these women. All the hype about his being in jail for 2 days seems so unnecessary.


    1. I agree law has to be similar in all cases. I think judges have scope to apply quantum of sentence. Two women whose life were permanently damaged, did they get justice?

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I am not aware if the quantum of sentence can vary with the financial status of the person. Ideally, he could have been levied a fine of Rs 50 crores of so and asked to finance and support the wildlife conservation efforts for the next 25 years maybe.


      2. That would have been a progressive and sensible. In India, we bay for blood without bringing about any meaningful change. In the US celebrities are asked to do community service. On one hand it brings humility on the person, on the other society would benefit.

        Liked by 1 person

      3. This man is no saint either. His own bodyguard Ravindra Patil, who was a constable and assigned to be his bodyguard by the state was the prime witness to the crime. When he lodged the FIR against him, he was shunned by all and left to die alone of TB while the hero walked way scot free. It actually makes no sense when such a person is idolized by the masses with all the constipated gestures he makes.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: